I am not sure of these numbers. I am 100% sure the listed ingredients are the cheapest to make the desired precursor, but I am not 100% on the average number of tries to get the precursor (the current estimate is from other people publishing their results - mostly from reddit's Nugkill).
Spirit Shard and Karma Items excluded (Allow SS and Karma items)
The Bard
Carcharias
Chaos Gun
The Chosen
The Colossus
Dawn + Dusk
The Energizer
Howl
The Hunter
Leaf of Kudzu
The Legend
The Lover
Rage
Rodgort's Flame
Spark
Storm
Tooth of Frostfang
Venom
Zap
Random Precursor from weapons
Random Precursor from any rare item
1 Mystic Forge Stone currently costs 16
59
15
to buy (It's only recommended to use it to take the place of an item worth more than that, or you get them for free)| Rare Ingredients | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Precursor | Price to MF | Ingredient 1 | Ingredient 2 | Ingredient 3 | Ingredient 4 |
 The Colossus Exotic Weapon Hammer 80 7.26+ / day  170 0002193 7499The cheapest 10 Rares used in the calculation | 4 bought Rares 247 5680(-33%) profit 781 attempts = 2,342 initial rares | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day |
| 3 bought + 1 crafted Rares 307 0007(-46%) profit 781 attempts = 2,342 initial rares | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day | Assassin's Godskull Crusher Rare 65, craft for 20 72Expand Recipe | |
| 2 bought + 2 crafted Rares 470 1333(-65%) profit 781 attempts = 2,342 initial rares | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day | Assassin's Godskull Crusher Rare 65, craft for 20 72Expand Recipe | Rampager's Krait Warhammer Rare 80, craft for 38 43Expand Recipe | |
| 1 bought + 3 crafted Rares 633 2659(-74%) profit 781 attempts = 2,342 initial rares | Cavalier's Verdant Warhammer Rare 80, buy for 10 574.23-+ / day | Assassin's Godskull Crusher Rare 65, craft for 20 72Expand Recipe | Rampager's Krait Warhammer Rare 80, craft for 38 43Expand Recipe | Rampager's Krait Warhammer Rare 80, craft for 38 43Expand Recipe | |
| 4 crafted Rares 796 3985(-79%) profit 781 attempts = 2,342 initial rares | Assassin's Godskull Crusher Rare 65, craft for 20 72Expand Recipe | Rampager's Krait Warhammer Rare 80, craft for 38 43Expand Recipe | Rampager's Krait Warhammer Rare 80, craft for 38 43Expand Recipe | Rampager's Krait Warhammer Rare 80, craft for 38 43Expand Recipe | |
| Exotic Ingredients | |||||
| Precursor | Price to MF | Ingredient 1 | Ingredient 2 | Ingredient 3 | Ingredient 4 |
The Colossus Exotic Weapon Hammer 80 7.26+ / day 170 0002193 7499The cheapest 10 Exotics used in the calculation | 4 bought Exotics 201 2280(-18%) profit 139 attempts = 416 initial exotics | Dire Orrian Smasher of Intelligence Exotic 70, buy for 41 331.15+ / day | Dire Orrian Smasher of Intelligence Exotic 70, buy for 41 331.15+ / day | Shaman's Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, buy for 55 3718.39-+ / day | Shaman's Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, buy for 55 3718.39-+ / day |
| 3 bought + 1 crafted Exotics 360 1502(-54%) profit 139 attempts = 416 initial exotics | Dire Orrian Smasher of Intelligence Exotic 70, buy for 41 331.15+ / day | Dire Orrian Smasher of Intelligence Exotic 70, buy for 41 331.15+ / day | Shaman's Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, buy for 55 3718.39-+ / day | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | |
| 2 bought + 2 crafted Exotics 519 0725(-68%) profit 139 attempts = 416 initial exotics | Dire Orrian Smasher of Intelligence Exotic 70, buy for 41 331.15+ / day | Dire Orrian Smasher of Intelligence Exotic 70, buy for 41 331.15+ / day | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | |
| 1 bought + 3 crafted Exotics 692 6031(-76%) profit 139 attempts = 416 initial exotics | Dire Orrian Smasher of Intelligence Exotic 70, buy for 41 331.15+ / day | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | |
| 4 crafted Exotics 866 1336(-81%) profit 139 attempts = 416 initial exotics | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | Rabid Pearl Crusher Exotic 80, craft for 2 0811Expand Recipe | |
Help and Info:
● Gives a list of all precursors for you to select, then tells you the cheapest ways to make the precursor you selected by throwing them into the Mystic Forge.
● The top combination will have all purchased ingredients. The second combination will have 1 crafted and 3 purchased ingredients. The third combination will have 2 crafted and 2 purchased ingredients. The fourth combination will have 3 crafted and 1 purchased ingredients. The last combination will have all crafted ingredients. You can pick which you want to use.
● 'Precursor' is which precursor is being made, and the buy order and sell listing prices for that precursor.
● 'Price to MF' is how much it costs to buy all the ingredients that will give you 1 precursor (on average). % profit is if you're selling it. The price and number of items assumes you re-MF any products of failed attempts.
● 'Ingredient 1,2,3,4' is which are the cheapest ingredients to throw into the forge and how much to buy or craft them.
● These are all averages. That means there will be times when no precursor comes out for 1000 attempts, and times when you get 2 in a row, for example. The strategy is that with a statistically significant amount of tries, you will observe the average return.
Precursor Drop Rates:
Drop rates is from research posted on reddit from the production of 289 precursors.
1 in 5 promotes rare to exotic, but appears to have less chance of getting a precursor
Average level of ingredients needs to be at least 75 to guarantee a level 80 (and thus, a precursor)
1 in 139 attempts produces a precursor from exotic (start with 416 exotics, including throwing failures back in)
1 in 781 attempts produces a precursor from rares (start with 2,342 rares, including throwing failures back in)